Bad Medicine
Last Friday the 18th I managed to sneak off..(ok, so I got my boss to approve) to KL to go for eye check-ups to satisfy my curiosity. I left my house at 6.45am and arrived at my friend’s house around the same time in the evening.
My observations of some private doctors:
* If you don’t do your research or bring a report from an initial check-up, they won’t bother to perform a full test
The first Dr of the day is very prominent. I was advised to get his (name obscured to protect Dr’s identity) expert opinion on my condition. After telling the good Dr my problem, I was quicly asked to look into the eye contraption, and followed by manual spot-light check.
It was deduced that yes, I do have cataract. However, it was then I was informed that I have 2 holes in my retinas.
Nice.
He believed that the cataract isn’t serious, and I should delay surgery. Instead, buy photogray lense and come in for regualr 6-month check-ups to see the ‘progress’ of the cataract.
The holes in my retina however, is serious.
Naturally, after discovering you have another eye problem, you have all these questions. I didn’t appreciate that the Dr was trying to ’shoo’ me out the door by speaking at faster, and not anwering any of my questions. What was annoying is how most of the advice was on quickly I should get my operation. Imagine, I had all these questions and it was left for me to find the answers on my own.
Not surprisingly, I was charged 3 times more than the first Dr.
Nice.
Then, I decided to get a 3rd opinion. The 3rd Doc performed an additional test and concluded that I have cataract, but I do not have a serious issue with the holes in my retinas. He advised me to come in for regular 6 monthly check-ups.
I was charged some where between the 1st and the 2nd Doc.
In a nutshell, here is the chronology of conclusion:
Doc #1
- Performed a one-process-check-up
- Discovered congenital cataract
- Advised to go for surgery
- Charged RM 50
Doc #2
- Performed a 2-process-check-up
- Confirmed Cataract
- Discovered holes in the retina
- Dissented from the cataract removal surgery
- Encouraged surgery to correct the holes in my retinas
- Charged RM 165
Doc #3
- Performed a 3-process check-up
- Confirmed the 2 problems above
- Advised against having any surgery since it is not critical
- Charged RM 105
The issues are:
- Why isn’t there a standard process for an eye check-up (or any check-up)? I knew if I didn’t know about these popular ailments they would not have cared to perform the additional processes. I was outraged as I failed to understand how Doc #1 didn’t even detect the holes in my retinas.
- How can Doctors have very different views on the same topic? Yes, many things are subjective, but hey, if holes in your retina is serious, then show me how serious and stop telling me to do an operation when you can’t back it up with facts.
- At the ridiculous rate that you’re charging your patients, at least perform a FULL check-up. Nobody is dieing in your department that day nor were there any patients with critical problems.
Then I realized that many practicing Docs in the private hospitals and clinics don’t really care about the welfare of their patients. If they did, they would have bothered to ask you about your condition, they would have performed all necessary tests, and given the best medical advice. Furthermore, just because people pay more, doesn’t mean they will give the best service or care for your more. It only means they get more money. I’m not saying all are like this, but 3 out of 3 that I met are. Wait, is it an ASian thing? (giggles)
Last resort, go to a Govt Hospital and get an advice.
That check-up will have to be in mid-July.
Darnit.
On the flipside of things, it does put the pressure off of me. I will delay ALL surgeries until I have more info.
Until then, it’s photogray glasses and buh bye contacts (sob sob). The brightside is, I still have my eyes. Alhamdulillah
-Asma Wan signing off-